The recent discourse led by Bruno Siciliano, professor of automatica and robotica at the Università Federico II di Napoli, signals a decisive shift away from the sensational pursuit of humanoid robots that aim to break human speed records. Instead, he urges the European robotics community to concentrate on developing physical artificial intelligence that is deliberately designed for seamless interaction with people. This perspective reframes the technology race not as a contest of who can build the most human‑like machine, but as an opportunity to create systems that augment human capabilities in everyday environments. By prioritizing cooperation over replacement, the focus moves toward solving real‑world challenges such as reducing physical strain in logistics, supporting mobility‑impaired individuals, and enhancing service sectors where human touch remains indispensable.
Siciliano’s skepticism toward fully anthropomorphic humanoids stems from practical considerations that often outweigh their visual appeal. He points out that a complete human‑like form, with legs and intricate balance mechanisms, introduces substantial cost, stability, and agility challenges, especially within constrained industrial spaces. The BMW experiment in South Carolina, where Figure AI’s humanoids were trialed and later reconsidered, serves as a concrete illustration of how the added complexity of legs can diminish productivity compared to simpler fixed‑base arms or wheeled platforms. Moreover, regulatory frameworks for safety and operational approvals lag behind the rapid deployment of such sophisticated machines, further eroding the expected return on investment for manufacturers.
The notion of “dark factories”—fully automated sites where humanoids operate without human presence and even without lighting—has been dismissed by Siciliano as an unrealistic and undesirable vision for Europe. He argues that the most effective scenarios for physical AI today involve cohabitation, where robots and workers share tasks in a complementary fashion. Examples demonstrated at the European Parliament in Brussels showed robots disassembling electronic devices, delivering parcels in urban settings, and clearing tables, all while humans supervised or collaborated. These use cases highlight how robots can take over repetitive, physically demanding sub‑tasks, allowing human workers to focus on decision‑making, quality control, and customer interaction.
To turn this vision into a structured industrial policy, Siciliano and fellow experts from the euRobin network have advocated for an AI‑based Robotics Act modelled after the successful Chips Act. The proposal calls for a public investment of thirty billion euros aimed at securing a thirty‑three percent share of the global robotics market by 2035. Such funding would not only support research and development but also stimulate the creation of open standards, shared testing infrastructures, and scale‑up incentives for small and medium‑sized enterprises. By mirroring the Chips Act’s approach of combining public money with private sector matching, Europe hopes to de‑risk early‑stage innovations while ensuring that the benefits remain broadly distributed across the continent.
The Brussels showcase provided tangible proof of concept for the proposed act. Robots were seen performing delicate electronic disassembly, a task that demands precision and careful handling of fragile components—a scenario where human fatigue could lead to errors. Urban parcel delivery demonstrated navigation through dynamic pedestrian traffic, underscoring the importance of robust perception and decision‑making algorithms. Table clearing, while seemingly simple, required adaptive grasping and spatial awareness in a semi‑structured environment. Collectively, these demonstrations illustrated that the immediate value of robotics lies not in replicating human locomotion but in augmenting specific workflow steps where consistency, strength, or endurance is needed.
Beyond factories and warehouses, Siciliano emphasizes sectors where human‑robot interaction can deliver outsized societal benefits. In transportation, collaborative cobots could assist with loading and unloading heavy luggage, reducing occupational injuries among airport and railway staff. In logistics, mobile manipulators could work alongside pick‑and‑pack operators to handle bulky items, thereby cutting down on musculoskeletal strain. The healthcare and personal assistance domains present perhaps the most compelling arena: robots equipped with gentle force feedback could support patient rehabilitation, monitor vital signs, or aid elderly individuals with daily chores, complementing rather than replacing human caregivers. Advanced exoskeletons, another area of ongoing research, can further amplify human strength while preserving the worker’s agency.
At present, Italy’s native humanoid manufacturing base is remarkably thin, with only a handful of companies active in the space. Government narratives that stress sovereignty and self‑sufficiency risk overlooking the strategic advantage of leveraging globally available hardware while concentrating European ingenuity on software, services, and integration. Siciliano contends that Europe’s historical strength lies in applying robotics to social and service contexts—think of assistive devices, collaborative manufacturing cells, and public‑space automation—rather than chasing purely factory‑centric, human‑mimicking designs. By nurturing this distinct identity, the continent can avoid merely replicating the US venture‑capital frenzy or the Chinese state‑driven scale‑up model.
The geopolitical landscape adds another layer of complexity. Europe finds itself sandwiched between a heavily subsidized Chinese robotics ecosystem, where state backing enables rapid deployment of low‑cost hardware, and an American environment where abundant venture capital fuels aggressive experimentation but often leads to fragmented, short‑lived ventures. Siciliano argues that instead of attempting to match either extreme, Europe should articulate a middle path that capitalizes on its regulatory rigor, strong engineering traditions, and focus on societal impact. This approach would allow European firms to differentiate themselves through reliability, safety certifications, and user‑centric design—attributes that are increasingly valued in markets wary of opaque AI systems.
Openness to foreign hardware, particularly from China, is presented not as a weakness but as a strategic enabler. Siciliano offers the example of a guide‑dog robot being developed at Federico II: the platform originated from a Swiss‑made quadruped chassis, while the true innovation lies in an intelligent leash that interprets sensor data to assist visually impaired users. If the underlying hardware is openly licensed and devoid of hidden security risks, adapting a less‑expensive Chinese‑made base could accelerate deployment and free up resources for higher‑value software layers, data analytics, and service models. This mirrors the broader trend in sectors like smartphones, where global supply chains coexist with localized innovation ecosystems.
Nevertheless, the enthusiasm surrounding robotics carries the risk of a speculative bubble, akin to the over‑optimism seen in certain tech cycles. Unrealistic expectations about rapid returns, combined with hype‑driven valuations, could lead to misallocation of capital and eventual disillusionment. Siciliano urges stakeholders to ground investment decisions in clear, measurable key performance indicators such as reductions in cycle time, improvements in worker safety, or increments in service availability. Public funding programmes should incorporate rigorous milestones, transparent reporting, and claw‑back mechanisms to ensure that money flows toward projects delivering tangible socioeconomic benefits rather than flashy prototypes with limited market fit.
For policymakers, the recommended course includes establishing open‑hardware reference designs, creating regulatory sandboxes where collaborative robots can be tested in real‑world urban and industrial settings, and offering tax credits or grants that specifically target software, AI algorithms, and service‑layer innovations. Investors should scrutinize start‑ups not merely for the novelty of their robotic form factor but for the defensibility of their data models, integration platforms, and after‑sales support ecosystems. Corporations looking to adopt robotics are advised to begin with pilot projects that augment existing workflows—such as adding a cobot arm to a packaging line or deploying a mobile base for intra‑factory transport—before contemplating more ambitious humanoid deployments. Continuous workforce upskilling programs will also be essential to ensure that human employees can effectively supervise, maintain, and collaborate with their robotic counterparts.
In conclusion, the path forward for Europe’s robotics ambition lies in embracing a human‑centric, pragmatic vision rather than chasing the spectacle of record‑breaking humanoids. By allocating substantial public funds through an AI‑based Robotics Act, fostering open hardware collaboration, and focusing on sectors where robots genuinely complement human labor, the continent can carve out a distinctive niche in the global market. Achieving the target of one‑third of worldwide robotics revenue by 2035 will depend on sustained commitment to standards, safety, and societal value, coupled with a willingness to learn from global supply chains while innovating at the software and service layers. Stakeholders who act on these insights today will be well positioned to shape a resilient, inclusive, and prosperous robotic economy for tomorrow.